Review: Emanuel Ax Weathers Beethoven’s Emotional Storms at Carnegie Hall

Review: Emanuel Ax Weathers Beethoven’s Emotional Storms at Carnegie Hall

By

The New York Times

28 April 2016

Describing a pianist’s performance as unhinged might seem like an unlikely compliment. But the adjective could be applied in the most flattering terms to Emanuel Ax’s engrossing interpretation of Beethoven’s “Pathétique”Sonata on Wednesday evening at Carnegie Hall.

The sonata was included on an all-Beethoven lineup, with two popular sonatas bookending three lesser-known pieces. Mr. Ax brought demonic power to the “Pathétique,” which opened the program. In the opening section, he revealed with particularly vivid colors the contrast between crashing low chords and the yearning melody in the upper register. His clarity of line was admirable in the tumultuous thickets of the first movement; the ethereal Adagio unfolded with a gorgeous simplicity; and he imbued the third-movement Rondo with seething tension.

After the tumult of the “Pathétique,” Mr. Ax offered a lighthearted contrast, a delightful and delicately shaded interpretation of the Six Variations on an Original Theme in F (Op. 34). Beethoven wrote the “Pathétique” during what historians have recognized as his early period, when he was already challenging the precedent of Viennese Classicism established by composers like Mozart and Haydn. He continued to break new ground in his middle period, when he composed the “Appassionata” Sonata. Mr. Ax brought passion and power in admirable measure to his performance, which concluded the program on a stormy note.

Beethoven’s Sonata No. 16 in G is perhaps the least often programmed work of his Opus 31 set, which includes the famous “Tempest” Sonata. It received an insightful and elegant performance here. Mr. Ax played the runs in the first movement with sparkling energy; the trills of the Adagio unfolded with leisurely grace, and the concluding Rondo with both strength and charm.

The second half of the program included an unfamiliar short bonbon: thePolonaise in C (Op. 89), which Beethoven wrote in 1814 for festivities at theCongress of Vienna and dedicated to a visiting czarina. After all the dramatic Beethovenian moods, Mr. Ax offered a gentle encore: an introverted rendition of Schubert’s “Der Müller und der Bach,” in Liszt’s transcription.

Leave a Reply

NY Phiharmonic

Artist-in-Residence: Emanuel Ax 2012/13.
Read more »

WATCH

Next Concerts

    March 30, 2017

    Paris, France

    Concert, Philharmonie de Paris, PARIS

    Programme: MOZART Piano Concerto No 22, K482

    Other Performers: Orchestre de Paris
    Conductor: Dohnanyi

    April 6, 2017

    Munich, Bavaria

    Concert, Symphonieorchester des Bayerischen Rundfunks, MUNICH

    Programme: MOZART Piano Concerto No 22 in E flat, K482

    Other Performers: Bayerishcher Rundfunk
    Conductor: Mariss Jansons

    April 9, 2017

    Lucerne, Switzerland

    Concert, Kultur- und Kongresszentrum, LUCERNE

    Programme: MOZART Piano Concerto No 22 in E flat, K482

    Other Performers: Bayerishcher Rundfunk
    Conductor: Mariss Jansons

    April 15, 2017

    Portland, ME

    Portland Ovations

    Programme: FRANZ SCHUBERT Four Impromptus Op 142 • D 935 (1827)
    SAMUEL ADAMS Impromptus (2015-16)

    1) Schubert – No 1 in F minor
    2) Adams – “10.17.2017”
    3) Schubert – No 2 in Ab major
    4) Adams – after Franz Schubert
    5) Schubert – No 3 in Bb major
    6) Adams – after my very young life
    7) Schubert – No 4 in F minor

    Samuel Adams’ ‘Impromptus’ has been commissioned by Music Accord, the North American consortium of classical music presenting organizations.

    – Interval –

    CHOPIN Impromptu in A flat, Op 29
    CHOPIN Impromptu in F sharp Op 36
    CHOPIN Sonata in B minor Op 58

     

    April 17, 2017

    Rochester, NY

    Eastman School of Music

    Programme: FRANZ SCHUBERT Four Impromptus Op 142 • D 935 (1827)
    SAMUEL ADAMS Impromptus (2015-16)

    1) Schubert – No 1 in F minor
    2) Adams – “10.17.2017”
    3) Schubert – No 2 in Ab major
    4) Adams – after Franz Schubert
    5) Schubert – No 3 in Bb major
    6) Adams – after my very young life
    7) Schubert – No 4 in F minor

    Samuel Adams’ ‘Impromptus’ has been commissioned by Music Accord, the North American consortium of classical music presenting organizations.

    – Interval –

    CHOPIN Impromptu in A flat, Op 29
    CHOPIN Impromptu in F sharp Op 36
    CHOPIN Sonata in B minor Op 58

    April 19, 2017

    Philadelphia, PA

    Philadelphia Chamber Music Society

    Programme: FRANZ SCHUBERT Four Impromptus Op 142 • D 935 (1827)
    SAMUEL ADAMS Impromptus (2015-16)

    1) Schubert – No 1 in F minor
    2) Adams – “10.17.2017”
    3) Schubert – No 2 in Ab major
    4) Adams – after Franz Schubert
    5) Schubert – No 3 in Bb major
    6) Adams – after my very young life
    7) Schubert – No 4 in F minor

    Samuel Adams’ ‘Impromptus’ has been commissioned by Music Accord, the North American consortium of classical music presenting organizations.

    – Interval –

    CHOPIN Impromptu in A flat, Op 29
    CHOPIN Impromptu in F sharp Op 36
    CHOPIN Sonata in B minor Op 58

    April 22, 2017

    New York, NY

    Carnegie Hall

    Programme: FRANZ SCHUBERT Four Impromptus Op 142 • D 935 (1827)
    SAMUEL ADAMS Impromptus (2015-16)

    1) Schubert – No 1 in F minor
    2) Adams – “10.17.2017”
    3) Schubert – No 2 in Ab major
    4) Adams – after Franz Schubert
    5) Schubert – No 3 in Bb major
    6) Adams – after my very young life
    7) Schubert – No 4 in F minor

    Samuel Adams’ ‘Impromptus’ has been commissioned by Music Accord, the North American consortium of classical music presenting organizations.

    – Interval –

    CHOPIN Impromptu in A flat, Op 29
    CHOPIN Impromptu in F sharp Op 36
    CHOPIN Sonata in B minor Op 58

    May 3, 2017

    Evanston, IL

    North Western University

    Programme: FRANZ SCHUBERT Four Impromptus Op 142 • D 935 (1827)
    SAMUEL ADAMS Impromptus (2015-16)

    1) Schubert – No 1 in F minor
    2) Adams – “10.17.2017”
    3) Schubert – No 2 in Ab major
    4) Adams – after Franz Schubert
    5) Schubert – No 3 in Bb major
    6) Adams – after my very young life
    7) Schubert – No 4 in F minor

    Samuel Adams’ ‘Impromptus’ has been commissioned by Music Accord, the North American consortium of classical music presenting organizations.

    – Interval –

    CHOPIN Impromptu in A flat, Op 29
    CHOPIN Impromptu in F sharp Op 36
    CHOPIN Sonata in B minor Op 58

Audio Player


Beethoven: Piano Concerto No. 4
Brahms: Music For 2 Pianos
Haydn: Piano Sonatas
Liszt: Piano Sonata in B Minor
Mendelssohn: Piano Trios
Strauss: Enoch Arden

LISTEN

Video Player

Extract from masterclass given by Emanuel Ax on Beethoven Piano Sonatas and Variations. The student is Nicolas Van Poucke. The full masterclass is available on DVD from www.masterclassfoundation.org

WATCH

Twitter